More than meets the eye: What shapes our views of refugees
Imagine a group of newcomers into your local area. Would you expect your neighbors to welcome them or react with reluctance? Would it make a difference how many men and women were in the group, or wehther they appeared white or non-white?
With these questions in mind, Chia-Jung Tsai and colleagues investigated expectations of local reactions to refugee arrivals in the northeastern German state of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania. The researchers wanted to dig deeper, exploring which concerns might underlie these expectations and whether women and men viewed the situation in the same way. What they found was not always what they expected.
Putting Perceptions to the Test
Demography traditionally relies on censuses, population registers, and surveys to describe and understand population change. In recent years, researchers have increasingly turned to digital platforms, including social media, to reach potential study participants. Tsai and colleagues used targeted advertisements on Facebook and Instagram to recruit participants for an online survey experiment. Between March and June 2023, 376 people aged 18 to 64 in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania took part.
“We used what researchers call a vignette: a hypothetical situation presented through images and a short description,” Tsai explains. Each participant was randomly assigned to just one of seven scenarios, featuring AI-generated images of ten hypothetical newcomers. The images showed groups consisting entirely of men, entirely of women, or equal numbers of both. The physical appearance of the people depicted also varied. For the analysis, the researchers distinguished between images categorized as white and non-white, but these labels were not provided to participants. The accompanying text explained whether the newcomers were refugees or Germans moving from another part of the country, and provided additional information about their ages, educational background, language skills, and reasons for moving.
Respondents were then asked how accepting they thought their neighbors would be toward the newcomers. They were also asked about perceived competition for jobs or romantic partners, concerns about safety, and whether the newcomers would be seen as capable of adapting to German cultural norms. “We deliberately asked about neighbors rather than the respondents’ own attitudes,” Tsai adds. “This indirect approach can make it easier for people to answer questions about sensitive topics more openly, without fear of being judged.”
A Matter of Gender and Appearance
The composition of refugee groups mattered, but not always in the way one might expect. Respondents anticipated the strongest rejection of groups consisting entirely of non-white male refugees, in line with previous research.
Interestingly, however, groups with equal numbers of women and men were expected to face nearly the same levels of rejection as all-male groups. In other words, anticipated rejection increased significantly only when the newcomers were exclusively male, rather than increasing steadily with the proportion of men. Among all-male refugee groups, respondents expected significantly greater rejection of those in the non-white category than of those in the white category.
The researchers also examined differences between female and male respondents. Men anticipated more rejection than women when evaluating all-female or gender-balanced refugee groups; their responses did not differ significantly across scenarios. Women, by contrast, anticipated less rejection of all-female and gender-balanced groups. But their expectations shifted significantly when the group consisted entirely of non-white male refugees; in that case, their scores were almost identical to those of male respondents.
Looking at the concerns associated with these reactions, the researchers found that concerns about safety and perceived threats to German culture stood out, especially for all-male, non-white refugee groups. Here again, men and women showed different priorities: female respondents expected particularly strong concerns about cultural change and competition for romantic partners when the newcomers were exclusively non-white men, whereas competition for jobs played a more prominent role among male respondents.
Beyond Acceptance and Rejection
The study offers only a limited snapshot: it involved a small sample from a single German state, with older people overrepresented, and measured expectations about hypothetical situations. To reduce bias linked to the sample’s composition, the researchers used a method called post-stratification, which adjusts how much weight different participants’ answers carry in the results. Even so, the experiment illustrates how complex perceptions of newcomers can be. Had the study been conducted elsewhere in Germany or with a different group of participants, the results might have differed.
The findings also have implications for public debate and policymaking. The results paint a more nuanced picture than a simple divide between people who welcome refugees and those who reject them. Neither refugee populations nor receiving communities are homogeneous: anticipated reactions depend on who is arriving, but also on who is evaluating the newcomers and what concerns they associate with their arrival.
A broader question is how these perceptions develop. When judging others, we rely not only on what we know about them, such as the information provided in the experiment’s short descriptions, but also on their appearance. How we interpret visible differences, in turn, depends on the social and historical context: people shown in the study’s non-white refugee scenarios, for example, might not be categorized in the same way in the United States. In other words, the meanings we attach to appearance influence assumptions about who belongs, who is different, and who might pose a threat. Researchers call this process “othering”: viewing people mainly as members of a group perceived as different from one’s own and attributing certain characteristics to them, rather than seeing them as individuals. In this sense, such judgments may reveal more about the expectations and fears of the receiving society than about the newcomers themselves.
Despite its limitations, the study points to the importance of understanding the diverse expectations and concerns within receiving communities. Recognizing these differences—and the stereotypes that may shape them—could help policymakers develop approaches tailored to local contexts rather than rely on one-size-fits-all solutions.
(Editor: Miriam Franchina)
JOURNAL
International Migration Review